Picture an FBI anti-corruption team asking whether three members of Congress traded defense money for campaign cash. Then picture the team disappearing. That is the core of a ProPublica investigation published Tuesday, and it is why so many people are searching for the Navatek bribery probe right now.
One caveat up front: every outlet running this story is working from ProPublica’s reporting. The allegations are not proven, nobody has been charged, and the lawmakers deny wrongdoing. So here’s the scoreboard as it stands.
Who the Navatek bribery probe named, and who it didn’t
According to ProPublica, agents were looking at Navatek, a defense research contractor, and its dealings with Sen. Lindsey Graham, Rep. James Clyburn and Rep. Joe Wilson. Note the titles. Clyburn and Wilson are House members, not senators, and Graham died in July at age 71. Our earlier report on his death covers that part of the story.
The FBI formally named two former Navatek executives, Duke Hartman and Joshua Knight, as subjects. The lawmakers, however, were not formal subjects. Agents told their superiors that could change.
Prosecutors never charged Hartman or Knight. As The Hill reports, they later co-founded a naval research firm.
What Navatek’s former CEO says in the Navatek FBI case
The heart of the case is the account of Martin Kao, Navatek’s former chief executive. He told the FBI that his business model consisted of bribing public officials in exchange for government contracts. He also said the research Navatek delivered was often worthless. (That is a striking thing for a contractor’s own CEO to say about the product.)
On Graham, Kao said the senator agreed to steer a $10 million contract to Navatek in South Carolina. In return, Graham would get a $100,000 campaign pledge. ProPublica says the two met at a Washington steakhouse in March 2020. There, Graham had required $40,000 in contributions for a 45-minute meeting.
Kao said Clyburn and Wilson struck similar deals after Navatek approached their offices in 2019. According to ProPublica, the FBI tallied $20,000 in donations from Kao and his family to Clyburn within days of their scheduled meeting.
This is where the story needs a caution flag. Kao is a convicted felon, and his account is an allegation, not an established fact. ProPublica says agents found it lined up with records seized from Navatek. Still, we have not seen those records.
Who is denying it
Graham’s office has been blunt. Spokeswoman Taylor Reidy now works for Darline Graham, the senator’s sister and appointed successor. Reidy said any allegation of quid-pro-quo behavior by the late senator or his staff is simply false.
The office says the FBI never contacted it. It also says Graham rejected the donations in question, and that the University of South Carolina had identified the project as a priority. A university spokesperson told ProPublica that officials knew of no political contributions from Navatek.
A Clyburn spokesperson also denied that donations bought influence. We have not confirmed the full wording of that statement. Even so, the denials are part of the record, and they matter as much as the Navatek investigation itself.
The money in the Navatek contracts scandal: your tax dollars
Here’s the thing: this is your money. The Senate Appropriations Committee, which includes Graham, released a budget report with $9.5 million for a Navy power and energy project. According to ProPublica, agents noted that an almost identical paragraph appeared in a Navatek executive’s internal spreadsheets.
Per The Hill, Navatek wanted more. Its larger goal was to get Congress to renew funding for two more years and two more projects, totaling $90 million.
ProPublica also reports that staff allegedly backchanneled with the Navy. The aim was to make contracting offices steer money to Navatek, even though the contracts were nominally competitive. If the contractor’s own CEO calls the research worthless, taxpayers deserve straight answers.
Who wins when the probe goes dark
This is the question everyone is asking, and the honest answer is that nobody was cleared. Nothing in the reporting says the lawmakers were exonerated. In fact, the investigation was past the tip stage, with a seized document trove and named subjects, when things changed.
ProPublica says Trump returned and almost immediately gutted the specialized FBI and Justice Department public-corruption teams. The purge swept up the two agents on the case. The career prosecutor helping them quit after Trump appointees barred the department’s anti-corruption section from filing new cases.
ProPublica describes the purge as revenge for Trump having been investigated himself. For more on the Justice Department’s recent turbulence, see our coverage of the Maduro torture charges.
That motive is the paper’s characterization. We found no on-record explanation from the FBI, Justice Department or White House. Outlets also differ on whether officials killed the probe, let it go dark or formally closed it. What the reporting describes is a team dismantled, not a case weighed on its merits and dropped.
Graham’s office argues it is unfair to publish after his death. Fair enough, but the money was federal, and the questions about it don’t expire.
What to watch in the Navatek bribery probe next
This is part two of an ongoing ProPublica series, and the first part covered Sen. Susan Collins. Watch for a response from the FBI, the Justice Department or the White House. Also watch for any demands for congressional oversight, and the next installment.
Meanwhile, the politics around Graham’s seat keep moving, as Trump’s backing of his sister shows.
The scheme, as alleged, was bipartisan, hitting Republicans and a Democrat alike. So the question isn’t which party gets burned. It’s why a case with seized records and named subjects ran out of people to work it.






